COVID-19 Notice: Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC is fully-operational during the COVID-19 global pandemic. We continue to handle cases and operate remotely, in accordance with mandated safety guidelines. We are available by phone, email or video conference to discuss your case.
Read More from Our Partners


over 900 million recovered for our clients

Helping New York and New Jersey Injury Victims for over 30 Years.


Medical Malpractice on Cruise Ships: Negligent Doctors on the High Seas

Maritime Law is slowly beginning to adapt to the modernization of the massive cruise line industry. Cruise companies are able to bypass many laws and regulations that consumers are accustomed to on the mainland. One such regulation is providing medical care while at sea. Although cruise liners now have medical staffs and facilities, there are no regulations as to what these facilities must contain or what the qualifications of the medical staff must be. Cruise ships have usually not been held liable for medical malpractice that occurs on their ships.

Troubled Waters Medical Malpractice on Cruise Ships - GLK law

The rule that has been commonly followed for nearly thirty years is the Barbetta rule which arose from the case of Barbetta v. S/S Bermuda Star under the U.S. Court of Appeals of the Fifth Circuit which has jurisdiction over Louisiana, Texas, and Mississippi. [848 F.2d 1364 (5th Cir. 1988).] Florence Barbetta suffered a coma due to a doctor not being able to identify that she had diabetes over a five day period. The Barbetta rule states that a cruise company is liable to hire a competent and effective medical staff. If a carrier fails to provide a qualified staff, then it is negligent. Any negligence on the doctor’s part does not reflect on the carrier. Thus, cruise ships are not responsible for their doctors’ negligence according to this rule. Doctors are not treated as employees, rather as independent contractors, and operate beyond the jurisdiction of most courts. This leaves consumers in an incredibly vulnerable position if they are harmed by the ship’s medical staff.

Shifting Tides

In November 2014, a new legal precedent was set in the Franza v. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd. case under the U.S. Court of Appeals of the Eleventh Circuit which has jurisdiction over Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. [772 F.3d 1225 (11th Cir. 2014).] Pasquale Vaglio, the father of Patricia Franza, who sustained a severe blow to the head while docked at port in Bermuda, was brought back on to the ship where he was not properly tended to until four hours after the injury at which point it was too late. Vaglio passed away a week later at Winthrop-University Hospital in Mineola, N.Y. as a result of the injury. Franza used the doctrine of actual agency, concluding that Royal Caribbean was negligent “by and through the acts of its employees or agents.” Franza also cited the doctrine of apparent agency because the ship had Mr. Vaglio believe that the doctor and nurse were acting as employees, or agents, of the cruise company.

The Voyage Ahead

Cruise companies must now be held to different standards than they were during centuries prior. As the ships have become incredibly high-tech and their capacities for passengers continue to increase, it is imperative to hold these companies to higher medical standards. It is especially necessary considering a dangerous medical condition at sea could quickly become much more severe or fatal. Not only are laws governing the conduct of these ships somewhat ancient, but laws to deal with the fallout are too. The same way that these ships are to carry safety boats and life-jackets, they should be required to have a certain number of qualified doctors on staff as well as certain necessary medical supplies in case of emergency. Although holding doctors liable can be a complicated matter, it is a pragmatic first step to hold the companies liable to encourage them to raise the level of their medical staff and facilities as well as providing compensation for those who have been harmed.

Client Testimonials

I am giving this law firm 6 out of six thumbs up. Very professional very personal and compassionate staff. From the Attorneys to the staff they were all...
Anthony C.
La mejor firma de abogados, muy profesionales, excelentes persona, todo el tiempo estuvieron pendientes de mi y mis necesidades, estoy muy agradecida con ellos.
Maricela O.
I was injured in 2011 and spent nearly 8 years with Ed Gersowitz and Jeff Korek. Their professionalism and care was beyond. The process was long and at times exhausting but Ed. Jeff and their team made me feel comfortable and in great hands. I... can't thank them enough and would highly recommend GLK to all. Thank you for all your help!read more
Jeremy N.
They were incredibly professional and pleasant to work with. They made the personal injury process straightforward and easy to navigate. I appreciated their...
Lindsay L.
Ed Gersowitz and all his colleagues at the firm Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC far exceeded all my expectations for a personal injury law firm. From the moment...
Robin F.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek and special thanks to attorney Daniel, Avi and Annette for all your help on my case. Dealing with the law...
Hazel M.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek, and especially to our wonderful attorney Anthony Makarov. Mr. Makarov was our trial attorney who took our...
Amy L.
A few years ago I was misdiagnosed and nearly ended up becoming a quadriplegic. Three spinal fusions followed. I asked my sister, a top D.C. lawyer, to find the name of the best personal injury lawyer in NYC, and I was referred to Jeff Korek of... Gersowitz Libo and Korek. It was a tough time for me, but Jeff and Irene were great and helped me through it every step of the way. They were compassionate, understanding and very accommodating, yet professional and always with their fingers on the pulse. They really care about the welfare of their clients, and not just money driven. When I was unable to travel, Jeff came to me, and I live an hour from the city. This firm is well known, well established, and has earned the respect and credibility among its peers. I highly recommend the firm of Gersowitz Libo and Korek without hesitation and, in fact, I already have. My thanks go out to the entire team for a better than expected outcome!!! They get a 5 out of 5 stars from me!!read more
Mary S.
From beginning to end we were comfortable with the team at GLK. Thank you Mr. Gersowitz (Ed) for obtaining a settlement out of court.
Donna L. S.
Jeff and Michael are both very professional and helpful towards my case. I would like to thank the team and Irene, the assistant, for all their help despite the length of time that the case took. They took a lot of care and were patient with... answering any inquiries that I more
Cindy C.
section start
Need Help with an Injury? We're Here to Help. Contact Us Today:
  • Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.