COVID-19 Notice: Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC is fully-operational during the COVID-19 global pandemic. We continue to handle cases and operate remotely, in accordance with mandated safety guidelines. We are available by phone, email or video conference to discuss your case.
Read More from Our Partners


over 900 million recovered for our clients

Helping New York and New Jersey Injury Victims for over 30 Years.


The Power of Fine Print- NJ Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Gym over Injured Member

New York Law Protects Consumers from Outcomes like This

Injury Attorney Jeff Korek at Supreme CourtAre you one of the many New Jersey residents who have joined a gym over the past few years in an effort to get healthier? Did you sign a contract that you assumed only bound you to certain monthly payments and expectations of keeping the equipment you use clean and being courteous to your fellow gym warriors?

Perhaps you should reread that contract you signed. Recently, the New Jersey Supreme Court upheld a ruling that a NJ gym wasn’t responsible for faulty equipment that injured a member of the gym in the case of Stelluti v. Casapenn Enterprises.

The gym member, Gina Stelluti, went to stand up on her stationary bike during a spin class when the adjustable handlebars dislodged and caused her to fall forward. Since her feet were strapped into the pedals, she ended up cracking her tooth and hurting her neck and back, causing chronic pain.

Stelluti sued the gym for her injuries, alleging that the club   had failed to maintain the bicycle properly, provide adequate warnings and instruction on the safe use of the bicycle, or adequately train and supervise its employees.

The gym she belonged to- Powerhouse Gym– claimed that they weren’t responsible since she signed a non-negotiable exculpatory agreement. The fine print of the waiver form included wording that the gym will not be held liable for the   use of all amenities and equipment, the sudden and unforeseen malfunctioning of any equipment, and the gyms instruction, training [or] supervision.

Subsequently, the Court granted summary judgment in favor of Powerhouse Gym. According to the official Supreme Court transcripts, the presiding judge called the signed waiver agreement unambiguous and enforceable, regardless of whether defendant conduct is characterized as negligence or as gross negligence.

The Supreme Court upheld this ruling on a 5-2 vote. The court stated this in their ruling: The agreement did not, and could not, shield the club from more extreme conduct such as reckless, willful or wanton, or palpably unreasonable acts or omissions diminishing the safe condition of its equipment. However, the Supreme Court held that there was no genuine issue of material fact that such extreme acts or omissions caused the plaintiff   accident.

In contrast to the New Jersey Supreme Court holding in Stelluti, New York has enacted legislation to protect consumers from the type of clauses illustrated above. New York General Obligations Law 5-326 specifically holds that exculpatory language cannot be used to shield gymnasiums and other places of public amusement and recreation from liability for their own negligence where payment or a fee is received. The law is very clear that such agreements and provisions are unenforceable and void as against public policy.   This law was enacted to protect consumers from the sort of fine print language at issue in Stelluti.

While it is clear that the exculpatory agreement that plaintiff signed in Stelluti, stated that the gym could not be held liable for faulty equipment, it is clearly unjust to allow physical fitness establishments to shield themselves from liability when they don’t maintain their equipment or they improperly supervise their staff.   Furthermore, the holding in Stelluti does not clarify what constitutes the sort of extreme, reckless conduct or omissions which would subject a gym to potential liability. In order to ensure that physical fitness and other public recreational establishments keep their facilities safe, it is crucial that New Jersey pass legislation which will hold gyms and health clubs liable for their own misconduct.

You can view a full transcript of the case at:

Client Testimonials

Ed Gersowitz and all his colleagues at the firm Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC far exceeded all my expectations for a personal injury law firm. From the moment...
Robin F.
I am giving this law firm 6 out of six thumbs up. Very professional very personal and compassionate staff. From the Attorneys to the staff they were all...
Anthony C.
A few years ago I was misdiagnosed and nearly ended up becoming a quadriplegic. Three spinal fusions followed. I asked my sister, a top D.C. lawyer, to find the name of the best personal injury lawyer in NYC, and I was referred to Jeff Korek of... Gersowitz Libo and Korek. It was a tough time for me, but Jeff and Irene were great and helped me through it every step of the way. They were compassionate, understanding and very accommodating, yet professional and always with their fingers on the pulse. They really care about the welfare of their clients, and not just money driven. When I was unable to travel, Jeff came to me, and I live an hour from the city. This firm is well known, well established, and has earned the respect and credibility among its peers. I highly recommend the firm of Gersowitz Libo and Korek without hesitation and, in fact, I already have. My thanks go out to the entire team for a better than expected outcome!!! They get a 5 out of 5 stars from me!!read more
Mary S.
I was injured in 2011 and spent nearly 8 years with Ed Gersowitz and Jeff Korek. Their professionalism and care was beyond. The process was long and at times exhausting but Ed. Jeff and their team made me feel comfortable and in great hands. I... can't thank them enough and would highly recommend GLK to all. Thank you for all your help!read more
Jeremy N.
They were incredibly professional and pleasant to work with. They made the personal injury process straightforward and easy to navigate. I appreciated their...
Lindsay L.
La mejor firma de abogados, muy profesionales, excelentes persona, todo el tiempo estuvieron pendientes de mi y mis necesidades, estoy muy agradecida con ellos.
Maricela O.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek, and especially to our wonderful attorney Anthony Makarov. Mr. Makarov was our trial attorney who took our...
Amy L.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek and special thanks to attorney Daniel, Avi and Annette for all your help on my case. Dealing with the law...
Hazel M.
Jeff and Michael are both very professional and helpful towards my case. I would like to thank the team and Irene, the assistant, for all their help despite the length of time that the case took. They took a lot of care and were patient with... answering any inquiries that I more
Cindy C.
From beginning to end we were comfortable with the team at GLK. Thank you Mr. Gersowitz (Ed) for obtaining a settlement out of court.
Donna L. S.
section start
Need Help with an Injury? We're Here to Help. Contact Us Today: