COVID-19 Notice: Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC is fully-operational during the COVID-19 global pandemic. We continue to handle cases and operate remotely, in accordance with mandated safety guidelines. We are available by phone, email or video conference to discuss your case.
Read More from Our Partners


over 900 million recovered for our clients

Helping New York and New Jersey Injury Victims for over 30 Years.


4 ½ Year Old Has the Mental Capacity to be Held Negligent

New York City sidewalkNew York City sidewalkNew York City sidewalkNew York City sidewalkMedical Malpractice AttorneyTwo 4 ½ year olds were racing their bicycles down a New York City sidewalk one afternoon when they accidentally crashed into an 87 year old woman and knocked her over. The woman required surgery after suffering a broken hip from the fall, and tragically passed away three months later. The family of the elderly woman is suing- not just the mothers of both children, who were present when the crash occurred- but also the children themselves.

In Menagh v. Breitman, the lawyer for one of the children argued that his 4  ½ year old client could not be held liable for negligence, and tried to get the case for that child dismissed.

James P. Tyrie first argued that his client should be treated as non sui juris (incapable of negligence) because of her age. There is a bright-line rule in New York that children under the age of 4 are incapable of being held liable for negligence.   However, there is no established law regarding negligence for children over the age of 4, and Tyries client was 4  ½.

Justice Paul Wooten felt that there was not enough evidence presented to increase the age of the bright-line law, and that cases of negligence brought against children over the age of 4 should be decided by a jury.Using language from the 1928 case of Camardo v. New York State, as quoted in Gonzalez v. Medina in considering the conduct of an infant in relation to other persons or their property, the infant should be held to a standard of care . . . by what is expected of a reasonably prudent child of that age, experience, intelligence and degree of development and capacity.

Tyrie also argued that his client couldn’t be held responsible because a parent was present to supervise the child. Justice Wooten concluded that the presence of a parent does not automatically eliminate a child’s negligence.Wooten stated  Because a child above the age of four will only be non sui juris if it is impossible under the circumstances to draw any other inference, parental supervision is unlikely to affect the sui juris status of a child above the age of four unless the parent has taken an active role in encouraging the child’s conduct.The fact that the mother was supervising her daughter racing her bike down the sidewalk does not mean that the mother actively encouraged the child to strike the elderly woman with her bike.

Justice Wooten brought up an example of a child running across the street.   A prudent 4  ½ year old child most likely knows the dangers of crossing the street without looking both ways.If an adult is present and that child decides to cross the busy road on his own without looking, there is a possibility that the child was negligent in doing so. The only way that child would automatically be non sui juris is if the adult told the child it was safe to cross the road, or encouraged the child to cross the road. The child could reasonably infer that it was safe to cross the road because a trusted adult told him/her to.

Justice Wooten’s ruling does not mean that the child is guilty of negligence for striking the 87 year old woman with her bike, but that it will be up to a jury to determine if she is negligent.

For additional articles on this case, check out The New York Times article entitled 4-Year-Old Can Be Sued, Judge Rules in Bike Case.

Client Testimonials

La mejor firma de abogados, muy profesionales, excelentes persona, todo el tiempo estuvieron pendientes de mi y mis necesidades, estoy muy agradecida con ellos.
Maricela O.
I was injured in 2011 and spent nearly 8 years with Ed Gersowitz and Jeff Korek. Their professionalism and care was beyond. The process was long and at times exhausting but Ed. Jeff and their team made me feel comfortable and in great hands. I... can't thank them enough and would highly recommend GLK to all. Thank you for all your help!read more
Jeremy N.
They were incredibly professional and pleasant to work with. They made the personal injury process straightforward and easy to navigate. I appreciated their...
Lindsay L.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek and special thanks to attorney Daniel, Avi and Annette for all your help on my case. Dealing with the law...
Hazel M.
I am giving this law firm 6 out of six thumbs up. Very professional very personal and compassionate staff. From the Attorneys to the staff they were all...
Anthony C.
Jeff and Michael are both very professional and helpful towards my case. I would like to thank the team and Irene, the assistant, for all their help despite the length of time that the case took. They took a lot of care and were patient with... answering any inquiries that I more
Cindy C.
A few years ago I was misdiagnosed and nearly ended up becoming a quadriplegic. Three spinal fusions followed. I asked my sister, a top D.C. lawyer, to find the name of the best personal injury lawyer in NYC, and I was referred to Jeff Korek of... Gersowitz Libo and Korek. It was a tough time for me, but Jeff and Irene were great and helped me through it every step of the way. They were compassionate, understanding and very accommodating, yet professional and always with their fingers on the pulse. They really care about the welfare of their clients, and not just money driven. When I was unable to travel, Jeff came to me, and I live an hour from the city. This firm is well known, well established, and has earned the respect and credibility among its peers. I highly recommend the firm of Gersowitz Libo and Korek without hesitation and, in fact, I already have. My thanks go out to the entire team for a better than expected outcome!!! They get a 5 out of 5 stars from me!!read more
Mary S.
From beginning to end we were comfortable with the team at GLK. Thank you Mr. Gersowitz (Ed) for obtaining a settlement out of court.
Donna L. S.
Thank you to the team at Gersowitz Libo & Korek, and especially to our wonderful attorney Anthony Makarov. Mr. Makarov was our trial attorney who took our...
Amy L.
Ed Gersowitz and all his colleagues at the firm Gersowitz Libo & Korek, PC far exceeded all my expectations for a personal injury law firm. From the moment...
Robin F.
section start
Need Help with an Injury? We're Here to Help. Contact Us Today:
  • Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.